Skip to content

Finding 3 of 4

Who wrote the "best agency" rankings that Gemini and ChatGPT cited?

Some "best agency" lists were written by agencies, and two more were agency-supplied rankings on media sites.

  • 196 of 1,513 Gemini citations that were lists ranking providers on agencies' own websites (13.0%)
  • 8 of 932 ChatGPT citations of the same kind (0.9%)
  • 24 Gemini citations of two agency-supplied rankings on media sites (ChatGPT: 0)
  • 17 Gemini answers that cited one ranking in a news site's "Announcement" section

What we found

Two of the cited pages were rankings of AI SEO agencies published on media sites as agency-supplied content. One, on a trade-media site, is marked "This post is sponsored by" an agency. The other sits in a news site's "Announcement" section and is marked as content provided by an agency. Together they drew 24 of Gemini's citations and 0 of ChatGPT's. Other "best agency" lists the engines cited were written by agencies ranking their own field. None of the answers that cited the two media-site rankings said they were agency-supplied.

Lists ranking or comparing providers, published on agencies' own websites, were 13.0% of Gemini's citations and 0.9% of ChatGPT's.

All 17 answers that cited malaysiakini.com cited one page: an agency-supplied ranking of AI SEO agencies in its "Announcement" section.

How we counted

Every cited page was coded by source type and publisher country.

A blind re-code of a random 20% sample of all the citations in both languages agreed with the first coding on source type for 92.6% of the sampled citations (Cohen's kappa 0.87).

English questions about marketing services in Malaysia, asked of Gemini and ChatGPT through their APIs in two windows (26 to 27 September and 4 October 2026).

What you can do with this

If you are choosing a provider an AI assistant named

Open the sources and check who published them. Before contacting a provider an AI assistant named, open the sources under the answer and check who published each one. A provider's own page, or its own list of the "best" agencies, is self-description, not a review.

If you want your own business to be found

Do not mass-produce pages or "best agencies" lists to get cited. Google treats using generative AI tools to produce many pages without adding value as spam, and a careful reader can see who wrote a list.

About the study

The questions were written for this study, not sampled from what businesses ask, and the engines ran through their developer APIs with fixed model versions rather than through the consumer apps. For ChatGPT, the audit counts the inline citations attached to each answer, not every page it read. The results describe this panel on these dates and show what was cited, not why.

ALIQ Studio sells AI-visibility services, so it has a commercial interest in this topic. Its own website was among the five most-cited agency websites in this audit.

Read the full section of the paper →

DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23970962

How to cite this finding

Yik Jinn, ALIQ Studio (2026). What AI answer engines cite when Malaysian SMEs ask for marketing help, v1.1. Finding: Some "best agency" lists were written by agencies, and two more were agency-supplied rankings on media sites. https://studio.aliqgroup.com/en/research/ai-answer-citations-malaysia-2026/best-agency-lists-written-by-agencies/. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23970962. CC BY 4.0.

Other findings from this study