Finding 1 of 4
What do Gemini and ChatGPT cite when asked about marketing services in Malaysia?
Mostly pages that marketing providers publish on their own websites.
- 1,322 of 1,513 Gemini citations that were providers' own pages (87.4%)
- 558 of 932 ChatGPT citations that were providers' own pages (59.9%)
- 627 of 728 Gemini citations for whom-to-hire questions that were providers' own pages (86.1%, exploratory)
- 307 of 362 ChatGPT citations for whom-to-hire questions that were providers' own pages (84.8%, exploratory)
What we found
Pages owned by agencies and freelancers made up 87.4% of Gemini's citations (1,322 of 1,513) and 59.9% of ChatGPT's (558 of 932). The study's first working hypothesis, that third-party pages would outnumber providers' own pages, did not hold on either engine.
Split by kind of question (an exploratory cut, added after the planned analysis), the gap between the engines comes mostly from questions about how a service works. For questions about whom to hire, providers' own pages were 86.1% of Gemini's citations and 84.8% of ChatGPT's.
The third-party pages differed by engine, as the study's second working hypothesis (that the two engines would cite different mixes of source types) expected. Government and industry-association pages were 17.1% of ChatGPT's citations and 0.1% of Gemini's. Google's own pages were 10.9% of ChatGPT's and 0.0% of Gemini's. ChatGPT cited both mostly for questions about how a service works.
Directories and review platforms were a small share on both: 1.2% for Gemini and 4.2% for ChatGPT.
For these questions, an assistant's recommendation mostly cited what providers publish on their own websites, so it may be closer to a summary of self-description than to an independent assessment. The engines may also have had few independent Malaysian sources to draw on. Either way, a provider named in an answer is a lead to check, not a verdict.
| Gemini | ChatGPT | |
|---|---|---|
| Providers' own pages | 87.4% (1,322) | 59.9% (558) |
| Third-party pages | 12.6% (191) | 40.1% (374) |
| All citations | 1,513 | 932 |
| Providers' own pages by kind of question (exploratory): share of that kind of question's citations | ||
| Whom to hire | 86.1% (627 of 728) | 84.8% (307 of 362) |
| How a service works | 85.3% (64 of 75) | 18.8% (57 of 303) |
| Cost | 88.9% (631 of 710) | 72.7% (194 of 267) |
How we counted
Each cited page counts once per answer.
For ChatGPT, these are the inline citations attached to each answer, which OpenAI describes as the most relevant subset of the pages consulted, not every page the model read.
English questions about marketing services in Malaysia, asked of Gemini and ChatGPT through their APIs in two windows (26 to 27 September and 4 October 2026).
What you can do with this
If you are choosing a provider an AI assistant named
Open the sources and check who published them. Before contacting a provider an AI assistant named, open the sources under the answer and check who published each one. A provider's own page, or its own list of the "best" agencies, is self-description, not a review.
Look for evidence the answer did not show. Look for client work you can verify, reviews on platforms the provider does not control, and the company's registration.
About the study
The questions were written for this study, not sampled from what businesses ask, and the engines ran through their developer APIs with fixed model versions rather than through the consumer apps. For ChatGPT, the audit counts the inline citations attached to each answer, not every page it read. The results describe this panel on these dates and show what was cited, not why.
ALIQ Studio sells AI-visibility services, so it has a commercial interest in this topic. Its own website was among the five most-cited agency websites in this audit.
Read the full section of the paper →
How to cite this finding
Yik Jinn, ALIQ Studio (2026). What AI answer engines cite when Malaysian SMEs ask for marketing help, v1.1. Finding: Mostly pages that marketing providers publish on their own websites. https://studio.aliqgroup.com/en/research/ai-answer-citations-malaysia-2026/ai-answers-cite-agency-websites/. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23970962. CC BY 4.0.