Skip to content

Finding 2 of 4

Did Gemini and ChatGPT search the web before answering who to hire?

For choosing a provider and for cost, almost always. For how a service works, it depends on the engine.

  • 84 of 84 ChatGPT answers about whom to hire that searched the web first
  • 82 of 84 Gemini answers about whom to hire that searched the web first
  • 73 of 84 ChatGPT answers about how a service works that searched first (86.9%)
  • 11 of 84 Gemini answers about how a service works that searched first (13.1%)

What we found

ChatGPT searched the web before every one of its 84 answers to questions about whom to hire, and Gemini before 82 of 84. For questions about how a service works, Gemini searched in 13.1% of answers and ChatGPT in 86.9%. An answer given without a search has no citations.

What was cited also differed by kind of question, mostly in ChatGPT's answers (an exploratory cut). For questions about how a service works, government and association pages made up 40.9% of ChatGPT's citations and Google's own pages 26.4%, against 0.0% and 0.0% for Gemini, which searched for few of these questions (Table 3). For questions about whom to hire, ChatGPT's shares were 4.4% and 0.8%.

ChatGPT's heavier use of government, Google and directory pages may reflect how often it searched for questions about how a service works, or a different search system behind it. This audit cannot tell which.

Table 3. Answers that searched the web before answering, by kind of question
Kind of questionGeminiChatGPT
Choosing a provider82 of 84 (97.6%)84 of 84 (100.0%)
How a service works11 of 84 (13.1%)73 of 84 (86.9%)
Cost78 of 84 (92.9%)84 of 84 (100.0%)
All questions171 of 252 (67.9%)241 of 252 (95.6%)

How we counted

An answer counts as searched when the API's response records a web search: a search query for Gemini, a web search call for ChatGPT.

English questions about marketing services in Malaysia, asked of Gemini and ChatGPT through their APIs in two windows (26 to 27 September and 4 October 2026).

What you can do with this

If you are choosing a provider an AI assistant named

Open the sources and check who published them. Before contacting a provider an AI assistant named, open the sources under the answer and check who published each one. A provider's own page, or its own list of the "best" agencies, is self-description, not a review.

If you want your own business to be found

Skip AI-specific files; make sure search crawlers can reach you. Google says it does not use AI text files or special markup. Instead, check that search crawlers can reach your site, including OpenAI's search crawler, and that your hosting or content delivery network is not blocking them.

About the study

The questions were written for this study, not sampled from what businesses ask, and the engines ran through their developer APIs with fixed model versions rather than through the consumer apps. For ChatGPT, the audit counts the inline citations attached to each answer, not every page it read. The results describe this panel on these dates and show what was cited, not why.

ALIQ Studio sells AI-visibility services, so it has a commercial interest in this topic. Its own website was among the five most-cited agency websites in this audit.

Read the full section of the paper →

DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23970962

How to cite this finding

Yik Jinn, ALIQ Studio (2026). What AI answer engines cite when Malaysian SMEs ask for marketing help, v1.1. Finding: For choosing a provider and for cost, almost always. For how a service works, it depends on the engine. https://studio.aliqgroup.com/en/research/ai-answer-citations-malaysia-2026/ai-assistants-search-before-recommending/. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.23970962. CC BY 4.0.

Other findings from this study